Hits:
Bakemonogatari- Creative animation styles, catching story, some of the best dialog I've heard in awhile.
Umineko no naku Koro ni- Holy crap. It's like Higruashi but waaaaaay cooler. I love this, the characters are amazing though this may be just because I'm in love with Beatrice.
Kobato- CLAMP YOU HAVE WON MY LOVE AGAIN!!! This isn't like the Tsubasa and xxxholic waste of tiem, they actually have expressions in the anime!!! The characters are lovable and the story, though a stereotypical "Let's find a bunch of this said item to reach my goal!", is fun and interesting enough to pull you. Plus USING CHARACTERS FROM MY FAVORITE CLAMP MANGA EVER (Wish). I nearly pooped my pants.
Kimi ni Todoke- Such a good Shoujo. I'm on my seat to see what happens in the next episode. I love the animation style they jump into when silly things are going on.
Kūchū Buranko (Trapeze)- Great music. Ibaru is such a hilarious character and I love the little things that you notice in the show that brings everything together (Symbolism with animal heads, connecting characters stories.) One of my favorites this year.
Darker than Black: Ryūsei no Gemini- The first one was great. I don't know how you could go wrong with the second series.
Eden of the East- Interesting and the art style was different then the usual and ugly huge anime eyes. The story was interesting enough that I'm scouring the internet for the 2 movies that are coming out!
On The Fence:
Tokyo Magnitude 8.0- It was very good and moving for the first half (I cried) but they started going into overkill in the second half (I won't ruin what happens) and the last episode was like "WTF ARE YOU PEOPLE THINKING".
Zan Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei- I hate to say it, but the materiel seems to be getting worse and worse with each season.
Hetalia: Axis Powers- It's good and all, but I find myself wanting to watch other things with more quality in an episode a lot of the time. That's the only reason why it's here.
K-On!- It was ok. So much gooey moe crap though...
Needless- Seemed bad in a good way. I'd need to catch more episodes to make a decision.
Misses:
Basquash- I HAD SO MUCH HOPE FOR THIS!!! The art style was so good but after the first three episodes the story started to become bland and it was all about T&A. SHAME ON YOU KAWAMORI!
GA Geijutsuka Art Design Class- It was cute, but not really catching at all. I stopped watching after the first episode.
Haruhi Suzumiya- I now hate Haruhi and will never watch it again. Endless eight was probably the most retarded thing in the world. I have better things to spend my time watching.
Nyan Koi!- Furrry crap. This was so god damn generic my best friend and I laid out how the first episode would pan out before we watched it, followed it to the T. BOOOOO.
Queen's Blade- No.
Toaru Majutsu no Index- It was so uninteresting I can't even remember what happened in that anime. I think I fell asleep.