VIP badges are nice for people who like to be treated well or for people who want
to really go to a con and not worry about lines and issues... and just do what they
please when they please... but that is not my personal philosophy on conventions
so I doubt I'd want one.
~Allykat
Ditto what Allykat said. Well... except that if by some miracle Kawasumi Ayako showed up, I'd buy one in a second.
Not for the other stuff, just for the guest dinner.
Just my guess, but I think the pricing represents a compromise - if someone reallyreally wants one and it's important to them, they
can get some privileges without having to be staff or know the right people. But for the rest of us, the price makes it unlikely that so many people would buy one that we'll get "bought out" of all the popular events.
I think you have an interesting point about upping the privileges it grants. Letting VIPs wander the dealer's room in the hour before opening shouldn't hurt anything, as long as there aren't too many
and they're willing to respect that not all the dealers will want to do (or be ready for) business. And a swag bag sounds great, but it might be troublesome to find things that everyone would want.
Last thing - I kinda see your point about the limited-seating guest dinner (in your specific case, the meet and greet), but they'd swamp the guests if they keep it open to everyone at a separate low price. Not a good way to get return guests, or have the kind of reputation that brings even better guests. And as you said, the guest dinner is most of the reason people would buy a VIP badge anyway.
(Sorry that this is so Kumoricon-specific when you're actually thinking about another con, but the same principles should apply.)