Agreed to an extent, was just responding to someone post that said that Mr Moore wasn't getting sued and thus was completely correct. I'm of the opinion that legal action does not nesicarly have anything to do with truth. Seems like a poor litmis test in my opinion.
That would be me. I also agree with you. I went and started reading the Michael Moore sited that talk about his films and argue against his claims. I found that there is quite a bit against him out there. As has been previousely stated this has mostly to do with his
Fahrenheit 9/11 film. Here are a couple of links that discuss his films in detail.
Michael Moore controversiesDave Kopel - Fifty-nine Deceits in Fahrenheit 9/11After reading these my opinion of Mr. Moore, is a little less than it was, but I still give him kudos for bringing to the attention of the US the many problems we have with believing everything we see on TV, even if it includes him. And the subjects of his films, are definitely things that should be brought to the attention of the American public.
u.s. census good enough for y'all?
% of uninsured skyrockets:
http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/567737
deaths from lack of insurance:
http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/healthcare/2002-05-22-insurance-deaths.htm
http://www.ncpa.org/sub/dpd/?Article_ID=6684&page=article
confirmed by american medical association:
http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2008/05/05/gvsc0505.htm
I love Michael Moore, he is one of my heroes. I couldn't care less who doesn't like him as a filmmaker, but anyone who thinks people don't die from lack of insurance is FULL OF @#$#.
I personally know of more than one person who died from lack of DENTAL CARE.
This is UNACCEPTABLE in this country or anywhere.
Rem, as much as I agree with you about Mr. Moore on his coverage of this issue, and his movie
Sicko, before you make him one of your heroes you may want to take a closer look at his stand on Israel. I think on that area you two are polar opposites. From what I read, he has angered quite a few of the Jewish people. I haven't researched this in any detail.
In short, I will bow to the statement that Mr. Moore isn't a reliable source. I still stand by my earlier examples from his film, though, as being actual examples of things that are wrong with the health care system. I admitted already, that they may be biased examples, and not fairly representative of the health care system as a whole. The facts still remain that people are dying because their health coverage won't pay for needed treatments, people have to determine which fingers to have re-attached (I suppose you can get them all done if you pay out of pocket), and people still pay $150 for an inhalent that they can get the generic version of for $0.05 in Cuba. These facts still remain, as well as many other things that the movie brings up.
I think the closest that this subject has to do with Obama is the idea of socialized medicine. I for one think it may be worth a try. It definitely couldn't be worse. I often read from the detractors of this that people have to wait long periods of time to get help, or that they have to schedule their appointments for urgent care, and may have to wait months. Are you talking about Canada or the US? It seems to me that most of that is true now for the majority of US citizens. My wife has a number of contacts in Canada that she talks with regularly. None of them ever had to wait more than 40 minutes to see a doctor.
I, personally, was having a bad reaction to my thyroid medication. My entire body was shaking, and I was sweating, and tired, because of insomnia. I called my doctors office, and was told my doctor was out, and that I could make an appointment to see a different doctor, how about 2 weeks from know? When I told them I thought the problem was my medication dosage, they said I could go to an emergency room and pay my deductible to have someone who didn't know anything about my medical history make a determination about my medicine. That people is a true account of US health care.
Oh and I missed work for 1 day. I lost my $800 yearly perfect attendance bonus, because I didn't see a doctor, and I didn't have a physicians note stating I was sick. Is that fair, or what?