I better go find an image on the web to link once I get a correct guess.
It is not Lombre (one vote at a time chica), vileplume, krabby, or that last one cthulhu voted for (summary doesn't go far enough back).
It's almost like I should just give the vote to Blastoise because he's trying harder than everybody else but I will keep to the arrangement.
Well it's a correction.
I am supposed to have that silly grin on my face. Once I looked up the pokemon itself I realized why I got confused, a similar pokemon is not smiling (so there, that counts as your clue). It will make sense once someone gets it right.
Everyone gets a new guess because nobody guessed the correct pokemon OR the pokemon I was getting confused with.