Huh...attractive huh?
Well, off of first glance for me it would be height. |D Since I'm short at 5'3", I like guys who are taller than me. 5' 9" or taller is the best for me.
I also like eyes so if a guy has pretty eyes then more points to him. A lot of people think brown eyes are ugly but there are so many different types of browns that it's not really. I don't have any specific color though.
I prefer lighter toned guys with a slight tan.
I also like them with an athletic build. Now, I don't need a six pack, I just like them to be nice.
For after the general outside, I like guys with smooth voices.
No offense, but I like my guys to have hit puberty, thanks. >.>
I also like them to be open & secure about themselves.
I crossplay as guys from time to time and I am open with who I am. I'm Bi so I don't mind hitting on girls if my crossplay calls for it and I would want him to be okay with that. I would also want him to be willing to hang out with me as a guy at a con and though I'm not the hugest fan of yaoi pairings, it wouldn't be bad.
But I also don't want him to be clingy, ya know? Clinginess is a huge turn off for me. I like to cosplay my things and he should like to cosplay his own. We don't always need to do pairings that end up together and we don't always need to be from the same series. I like to spend days where I don't touch my phone and I don't want to have to worry about 50 texts at the end of the day asking if I'm okay cause I didn't respond or 20 phone calls with 15 voice mails.
Edit: Not that I don't want to talk to them. But I like not being bugged by other people. We can talk over an IM or something on those days...
TL;DRI like guys who are taller than me, light skinned, & have an athletic build with nice eyes, a smooth voice, and comfortable with his own sexuality and mine. This includes being comfortable with me wanting to crossplay from time to time!