Yeah I do think Harmonix is doing things right with the competitiveness. I played the new GH at Aki-con and like I said in the Rock Band 2 topic, and that tofu stated, the notes seemed to not be part of the game. Another thing that didn't need to be there and also makes the game ugly is the create character thingy. It makes it ugly in two ways;
1: The graphics are disgusting, I loved how good the graphics were in 3, and Casey was super hot. On this one it looks like the PS3 version was the PS2 version.
2: Instead of staying "Guitar Hero" the creator is a blatant rip-off of Rock Band, it's something they added just because the enemy had it.
The gameplay to me was still just about the same, again, except for the notes seeming like they were going to fly out of the screen. oh and one thing that was kinda annoying but I guess doesn't matter all that much, the touch strip thing, why is there a lip on the bottom? Frets don't lift up at the bottom er side? of the fret. I liked the way the controller felt, except the strum bar. Why did they feel the need to make the strum bar exactly like the stratocasters? That felt really weird and I didn't like it too much, but the fret buttons felt nice in my fingas.
I think the best thing though, is the purple bar thing that lets you hammer-on/pull-off with out strumming as long as that bar thing connects the notes. That was really nice.
Honestly, I only really hate one song in the setlist, and I don't really have a problem with the rest of the songs, that I know of. I didn't get to see all the songs. However I do love the RB2 setlist incredibly more. Also, the songs that are in both GH:WT and RB2 were not nearly as fun on GH, specifically Ramblin Man!
Personally, when I play GH or RB it always feels kinda mechanical. I can get into the music because I know I can never play these songs on a realtar. I don't know how to explain this though.
All in all, I think I'll play both but if they somehow manage to make the next one worse then this, then I'll be a RB fan and not play GH anymore.
PS I think the reason there's so many songs on GHWT that are also on RB2 is because there is people out there who only buy the GH games, thus they want to give them at least some of what they are missing. Also, I still think the GH tournys can be used with this game, oh yeah, if I have to hear Eye of the Tiger one more time, I swear I'll start punching someone like a dead cow carcass! I seriously heard that damn song at least 15 times in an hour, ahhh my ears!!!